GEBE Fuel Clause: BTP Drafts a New Formula as the Court Case Over a Cg 12.6 Million Surplus Moves to December
The GEBE fuel clause, the line on every Dutch-side electricity bill that moves with fuel costs, is being rewritten. TEATT Minister Grisha Heyliger-Marten told Parliament this week that the Bureau Telecommunications and Post (BTP) is drafting a new fuel clause structure because GEBE did not submit the proposal the government asked for. In parallel, a consumer group's court case over the clause and disputed balances now waits on GEBE's written reply, due December 8, 2026.
What happened
A new formula, written by the regulator. Speaking during the debate on the draft 2027 budget (reported November 9), the minister said BTP's draft fuel clause structure should reach the government "within the coming weeks." A draft National Decree setting the base tariff structure, including categories of connections, would follow.
Why the old one failed. An April 2025 evaluation by RAC and BTP found GEBE's fuel clause formula could not be validated. It cited a timing mismatch in the calculation, fuel costs tied to potable water production, and a fixed percentage for non-revenue electricity instead of a measured one.
The surplus. The same review identified a surplus collected through the clause. The Daily Herald puts it at about Cg 12.6 million, roughly US$7 million at the 1.79 peg. The minister said nothing can be done with it until a broader cost-coverage analysis is completed and missing financial data is verified.
The court case. The Association for Consumer Protection St. Maarten (ACP-SXM) filed a petition at the Court of First Instance on September 15. It asks the court to confirm the fuel clause needs a lawful basis, to make GEBE back disputed balances with clear written evidence, and to bar disconnections over balances customers have not been able to verify. GEBE, now represented by a new attorney, was granted until December 8 to file its defence. ACP-SXM expects a substantive hearing in 2027.
Old balances. Many disputes go back to the 2022 cyberattack that disrupted GEBE's systems and records for months.
This follows the government's October announcement of a draft electricity tariff law, which we covered here. In May, the fuel clause rose to 0.45 guilders per kWh from 0.36 a month earlier.
What the GEBE fuel clause means for property
Running costs. Electricity is one of the biggest holding costs on the Dutch side. Air conditioning, pool pumps and water heaters run on it, and on a rental villa it is often the largest variable expense between bookings. A formula set by the regulator, with published inputs, would make that cost easier to forecast. It will not, by itself, make power cheaper.
Buyers. The court case is a reminder to treat the utility account as part of due diligence. Before the notary transfer:
Ask the seller for twelve months of GEBE bills, not one.
Ask whether any balance on the account is disputed, and since when.
Arrange a final meter reading on the transfer date and get written confirmation that the seller's account is settled.
Open the account in your name, or the new owner's company name, straight away.
Sellers. If you are carrying a disputed balance from 2022 or later, sort it out before you list. Buyers' lawyers ask, and an open dispute slows a closing that should take 30 to 60 days. Our guide to selling in Sint Maarten covers the paperwork buyers expect.
Landlords. Where a long-term tenant pays the GEBE bill on an account in the owner's name, a disputed or unpaid balance is still the owner's exposure. Check who the account holder is.
The French side is not affected. Saint-Martin is supplied by EDF under France's regulated tariffs.
Our read
This is the right direction, slowly. A regulator writing the formula, a decree setting the tariff structure and a court testing the legal basis add up to the kind of utility oversight our North American and European buyers already live with at home. None of it changes next month's bill, and the surplus question is unlikely to be settled before the 2027 hearing.
For buyers, this is not a reason to wait. It is a reason to price power into the numbers. A condo in a well-run Cupecoy or Maho building with shared services is a different running-cost proposition from a hillside villa in Pelican Key with two pools and older AC units. Ask for the bills, check for solar, inverter air conditioning and a generator, and compare like with like when you browse Dutch-side property for sale.
Sources: The Daily Herald, "BTP preparing new GEBE fuel tariff structure, minister tells Parliament" (November 9, 2026) and "GEBE requests more time to respond to ACP-SXM case" (November 12, 2026); Government of Sint Maarten news releases (2025–2026); Andreu Realty (October 2026). Read the Daily Herald report on the BTP formula and the report on the court case.




Comments