Indigo Bay Real Estate in Sint Maarten: Villas for Sale, Prices and the Setai Next Door (November 2026)
Indigo Bay is the gated hillside community on the south coast of Sint Maarten, between Cole Bay and Philipsburg, and the only Dutch-side address with a five-star hotel under construction on its own beach. As of November 17, 2026, Andreu Realty lists two new villa types there, at $3,250,000 and $3,708,000, both completed in 2025 and sold furnished.
Indigo Bay real estate: the answer in brief
Where: on the hillside above Cay Bay, on the south coast of the Dutch side, a short drive west of Philipsburg. One guarded entrance.
What you buy: villas and condos. In our September 2026 review, entry points were about $1.5 million for a villa and about $900,000 for a condo.
What we list today: Infinity Villas by Elie Saab, Frontline (4 bedrooms, $3,250,000, listing ID 11017) and Highline (5 bedrooms, $3,708,000, listing ID 11015).
What is coming: The Setai St. Maarten, with completion targeted for 2028.
How the purchase works: a civil-law notary on the Dutch side, 4% transfer tax paid by the buyer, about 5.5% in total buyer closing costs.
What is for sale
The two villa types we list are part of Infinity Villas by Elie Saab. Interiors are furnished by ELIE SAAB Maison, under the artistic direction of Elie Saab and designer Carlo Colombo, with furniture made in Italy. Every villa has its own infinity pool and jacuzzi, an elevator between floors, a garage, a smart-home system and sea views over the bay.
Frontline villas: 4 bedrooms, 5 bathrooms, $3,250,000 (listing ID 11017).
Highline villas: 5 bedrooms, 6 bathrooms, $3,708,000 (listing ID 11015).
Both are new, so neither has a rental track record yet. If your budget sits below this level, the wider island offers more choice: see every listing on our Sint Maarten villas for sale page.
The Setai next door
The Setai Hotels and Toronto-based Altree Developments announced The Setai St. Maarten on December 18, 2025: 205 keys at Indigo Bay, residences from one to four bedrooms, and completion expected in 2028, on the site previously marketed as Vie L'Ven (PR Newswire). In June 2026 the developer reported that vertical construction had started and that more than 40% of the residences had sold.
On the beach itself, the Court of First Instance ruled on June 23, 2026 that the Indigo Beach restaurant can stay, rejecting the developer's request to evict its operators (SMN News).
What it means for buyers: a branded resort tends to bring guests, restaurants and services that a private estate cannot support alone. It also brings two more years of construction traffic. Ask where your villa sits relative to the site and the access road. We looked at the wider effect in The Setai comes to Indigo Bay.
What to check before an offer
The estate fee: the amount, what it covers (security, roads, common areas, concierge) and the latest owners' budget.
The deed type: freehold or long lease (erfpacht). On the Dutch side, some land is held on long lease, and the notary will confirm which applies.
Delivery documents: for a new build, the completion paperwork and any warranties from the developer.
Rental rules: whether the estate rules allow short-term rentals and on what terms.
Running costs: management, staff, insurance, pool and garden care, utilities. Andreu Realty manages rentals for owners at a 20% fee.
Our read
Indigo Bay is a bet on what the bay will look like in 2028, not on what it looks like this winter. The villas are finished; the resort is not. Buyers who are comfortable with that timeline get new construction, sea views and a gated address ten minutes from Philipsburg. Buyers who want a proven rental income from day one should look at established buildings first.
At these prices, the details matter more than the view. Get the estate fee, the deed type and the rental rules in writing before you sign anything.
Questions we get
Can foreigners buy at Indigo Bay? Yes. Foreign buyers purchase on the Dutch side through the same civil-law notary process as residents.
How long does closing take? Usually 30 to 60 days, depending on financing and the parties involved, with a deposit of about 10% at signing.
Is there rental history for these villas? Not yet. They were completed in 2025. Ask us for comparable rentals at this level before you rely on a figure.
Sources: Andreu Realty listings (November 17, 2026); The Setai Hotels and Altree Developments, PR Newswire (December 18, 2025); Markets of Tomorrow (June 25, 2026); SMN News (June 25, 2026).




Comments